Abolishing House of Lords would spark ‘fundamental challenges’, Speaker warns
Former Labour MP Lord McFall will warn against creating an elected second chamber, saying voters care more about health and education.
The Speaker of the Lords is set to condemn Labour’s plans to abolish the second chamber, claiming changing it to a fully elected House would “present fundamental challenges”.
Sir Keir Starmer announced the plan on Monday – alongside former prime minister Gordon Brown – as the pair insisted a new Labour government would ensure “the biggest transfer of power out of Westminster and Whitehall [that] our country has seen”.
But while Lord McFall – once a Labour MP himself – agrees with the need to reform the red benches, he will criticise the direction the party is taking.
He fears it could “threaten both the balance of our constitution and our capability across parliament to deliver good and effective legislation”.
Giving a lecture to the Hansard Society in Westminster later today, he is expected to say: “The House of Lords needs to keep up with the times.
“If it doesn’t, it will decline, and that’s bad for our politics and our democracy.”
Lord McFall will recommend making the chamber “smaller, more inclusive and more representative of all parts of the United Kingdom”.
But he will warn about the need for buy-in to the plans from across the political spectrum, saying “previous failed attempts at far-reaching change illustrate that without agreement across parties even the most worthy proposals could be found wanting”.
The Speaker will also say the electorate “makes their decisions based upon the issues that matter to them” rather than constitutional reform, adding: “While I think that the future of the House of Lords is important, I am not certain it ranks above topics such as health, education and the economy for most voters.”Advertisement
Sky News contacted Labour for a response, but the party declined to comment.